Back to search

It's Time to Tear Down That 'Other Wall'

FHMI-1518Professor Toto2026-11-02Commentary Article

Searchable index text

This text comes from the vector search index, so keyword links can open directly to searchable content.

No exact match for "patrick henry 'when a people forget god'" in this transcript. This result may have matched scripture references, topics, or other metadata—check sections above.

Title: It's Time to Tear Down That 'Other Wall' Summary: Professor Toto teaches that the 'wall of separation' was built by persecuted Baptists to keep the government out of the church, not the church out of public life. In colonial Virginia, the Anglican establishment was paid by tobacco levies on all households and dissenting preachers were jailed for preaching without a license. Roger Williams first wrote of a wall protecting the church's garden from the wilderness of the world (1644), and Baptist petitions carried Jefferson's Statute for Religious Freedom in 1786. Jefferson's 1802 Danbury letter, followed two days later by his attendance at John Leland's sermon in the Capitol, shows its meaning. Justice Black's Everson ruling (1947) inverted it. IT'S TIME TO TEAR DOWN THAT “OTHER WALL” . . . Not the southern border wall, the southern Baptist one! The Seperation of Church and State, what do you really know about this subject? Professor Toto — TOTO FREE PRESS · Published 2026-11-02 · https://professortoto.substack.com/p/its-time-to-tear-down-that-other ________________ Let’s EDUCATE AMERICA. ? Professor Toto — TOTO FREE PRESS · Published 2026-11-02 · https://professortoto.substack.com/p/its-time-to-tear-down-that-other ________________ Let’s EDUCATE AMERICA. Say the words “separation of church and state” in any classroom in this country, and watch what happens. Somebody will tell you it means a pastor can’t speak on a moral issue. Somebody will tell you a coach can’t bow his head on a football field. Somebody will tell you a Bible verse on a courthouse wall is a constitutional crisis. Somebody will tell you it means the church must sit down, shut up, and keep its convictions inside four walls. And every single one of them has it BACKWARDS. Because the wall was real. But the wall was never built to keep the church out of public life. The wall was built to keep the GOVERNMENT out of the church. And the men who built it were not secularists. They were not atheists. They were not judges in black robes. They were BAPTIST PREACHERS — and many of them built that wall from the inside of a jail cell. ________________ THE CROWN CHURCH OF VIRGINIA Go back with me to colonial Virginia. were BAPTIST PREACHERS — and many of them built that wall from the inside of a jail cell. ________________ THE CROWN CHURCH OF VIRGINIA Go back with me to colonial Virginia. The Church of England — the Anglican Church — was not simply a church in Virginia. It was THE church. It was the established church, the official church, the government church. And the government paid for it. Now Class, write this down. By a Virginia statute dating back to 1696, every Anglican parish minister was owed an annual salary of sixteen thousand pounds of tobacco, plus extra for the cask. Tobacco was the currency of Virginia. Taxes were levied in tobacco. Salaries were paid in tobacco. And the parish levy that paid the parson fell on every taxable household in the parish. Do you see it? If you were a Baptist in Virginia, you went to YOUR church — and then the government reached into your tobacco barn and paid the salary of a preacher you did not hear, in a church you did not attend, teaching a faith you did not hold. The preacher’s paycheck came through the government. And whoever signs the paycheck owns the pulpit. ________________ ou did not attend, teaching a faith you did not hold. The preacher’s paycheck came through the government. And whoever signs the paycheck owns the pulpit. ________________ PREACHING WITHOUT A LICENSE But paying for someone else’s church was the gentle part. The Baptists were not merely taxed. They were HUNTED. On June 4, 1768, in Spotsylvania County, Virginia, the sheriff and magistrates rode up to a Baptist meeting and seized the preachers — John Waller, Lewis Craig, James Reed, and others. The charge? Preaching without a license. Read that again. In the colony that would give us Jefferson and Madison, it was a CRIME to preach the Gospel without the government’s permission slip. And Spotsylvania was only the beginning. Culpeper County jailed more Baptist preachers than any county in Virginia — James Ireland, Elijah Craig, Nathaniel Saunders, William McClanahan, and more. Services were broken up. Congregations were harassed. Preachers sat in jail for weeks — Waller for forty-three days. And tradition holds that some of them kept right on preaching — through the bars of the jail window — to the crowds that gathered outside. weeks — Waller for forty-three days. And tradition holds that some of them kept right on preaching — through the bars of the jail window — to the crowds that gathered outside. Historians have documented dozens of dissenting ministers jailed in colonial Virginia, and scores more who were beaten, mobbed, and dragged from their own meetings. Now let me ask you a question. When a man has been arrested for preaching, what kind of “separation” does he want? He doesn’t want the church to stay out of the government’s business. He wants the government to stay out of HIS PULPIT. ________________ THE BAPTISTS DIDN’T BORROW THE WALL. THEY INVENTED IT. Here is the part your textbook left out. The phrase “wall of separation” did not start with Thomas Jefferson. It started with Roger Williams — the man who founded Rhode Island and planted the first Baptist church in America. In 1644 — more than a century and a half before Jefferson — Williams wrote of a “hedge or wall of separation between the garden of the church and the wilderness of the world.” Look at that image. The church is the GARDEN. The world — the government, the politics, the power — is the WILDERNESS. rden of the church and the wilderness of the world.” Look at that image. The church is the GARDEN. The world — the government, the politics, the power — is the WILDERNESS. And the wall exists to protect the garden from the wilderness. Not the other way around. Roger Williams was not afraid the church would corrupt the state. He was afraid the STATE would corrupt the CHURCH. That is the wall. That was always the wall. The Baptists drew the blueprint, and YAHWEH’s garden was the thing it was built to protect. ________________ JEFFERSON AND THE BAPTISTS: THE UNLIKELY ALLIANCE Now enter Thomas Jefferson. Jefferson was no Baptist. He was not an orthodox believer by any stretch. But on this one issue, he and the Baptists stood shoulder to shoulder. In 1777, Jefferson drafted his Bill for Establishing Religious Freedom for Virginia. It was introduced in 1779 — the same year Jefferson became governor. And it STALLED. For seven years it sat there while the Anglican establishment and its allies fought back. Patrick Henry even pushed a plan to tax every Virginian to fund “teachers of the Christian religion.” Who broke the logjam? Anglican establishment and its allies fought back. Patrick Henry even pushed a plan to tax every Virginian to fund “teachers of the Christian religion.” Who broke the logjam? Not the politicians alone. While Jefferson was across the ocean serving in France, James Madison carried the fight in the legislature — and the Baptists and Presbyterians FLOODED the Virginia Assembly with petitions demanding that the government let go of the church. For every citizen who signed Madison’s famous Memorial and Remonstrance, many more signed the religious petitions from the dissenting churches. On January 16, 1786, Jefferson’s statute became law. The Anglican establishment in Virginia was finished. Jefferson considered it one of the three achievements of his life worth carving on his tombstone. And the Baptists never forgot who wrote it. ________________ THE LETTER FROM DANBURY Fast forward to 1801. Jefferson is now President of the United States. And up in Connecticut, another group of Baptists is suffering under another government church. DANBURY Fast forward to 1801. Jefferson is now President of the United States. And up in Connecticut, another group of Baptists is suffering under another government church. In Connecticut it was not the Anglicans — it was the Congregationalists who held the state establishment, and the Baptists were a tolerated minority. On October 7, 1801, the Danbury Baptist Association wrote to the new President. Listen to their words: “...what religious privileges we enjoy (as a minor part of the State) we enjoy as favors granted, and not as inalienable rights...” Favors granted. Not rights. They knew the difference — because they had lived it. They knew Jefferson’s record in Virginia. They saw him as a friend of religious liberty. And they wrote to him hoping he would stand with them. On January 1, 1802, Jefferson answered: w Jefferson’s record in Virginia. They saw him as a friend of religious liberty. And they wrote to him hoping he would stand with them. On January 1, 1802, Jefferson answered: “Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between Man & his God, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, & not opinions, I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should ‘make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,’ thus building a wall of separation between Church & State.” Now Class — read that letter slowly. Religion is between a man and his Maker. He owes the government NO ACCOUNT for his faith or his worship. The government’s power reaches ACTIONS — obeying the laws, keeping the peace — and NOT the convictions of the soul. That’s it. That is the entire meaning of the wall. The government does not tell you when you can gather. The government does not license your preacher. The government does not dictate your sermon. tire meaning of the wall. The government does not tell you when you can gather. The government does not license your preacher. The government does not dictate your sermon. The government does not tax you to pay for somebody else’s church. The wall keeps the GOVERNMENT OUT. ________________ AND NOW… THE REST OF THE WEEK But here is where it gets good. On that very same New Year’s Day — January 1, 1802 — Jefferson received a visitor at the President’s House. A Baptist preacher named John Leland. Leland had preached in Virginia during the persecution years. He had pastored in Culpeper — the very county that jailed more Baptist preachers than any other. He had fought for disestablishment alongside the dissenters. And he had come to Washington hauling a gift from the Baptist farmers of Cheshire, Massachusetts: A MAMMOTH CHEESE weighing some 1,200 pounds — made as a tribute to the President who stood for religious liberty. Then — just two days after writing the “wall of separation” letter — President Thomas Jefferson went to church. Where? In the Hall of the House of Representatives. In the United States Capitol. fter writing the “wall of separation” letter — President Thomas Jefferson went to church. Where? In the Hall of the House of Representatives. In the United States Capitol. And the man in the pulpit that Sunday was none other than John Leland — the Baptist preacher. Do you see it? The author of the “wall of separation” wrote the letter on Friday… and sat under a Baptist sermon inside the halls of Congress on Sunday. If the wall meant what the modern courts claim it means, Jefferson knocked it down with his own feet two days after he built it. He didn’t knock anything down. Because the wall was never meant to keep a preacher out of the Capitol. It was meant to keep the Capitol out of the preacher. ________________ HOW THEY FLIPPED THE WALL So how did we get from jailed Baptist preachers to a nation where a high school coach gets fired for praying? Here’s how. Jefferson’s letter sat in relative obscurity for most of the nineteenth century. The Supreme Court mentioned it in 1878, in Reynolds v. United States — and the line the Court leaned on was Jefferson’s point that government reaches actions, not opinions. Then came 1947. ourt mentioned it in 1878, in Reynolds v. United States — and the line the Court leaned on was Jefferson’s point that government reaches actions, not opinions. Then came 1947. In Everson v. Board of Education, Justice Hugo Black — a lapsed Baptist from Alabama — pulled Jefferson’s metaphor off the shelf and declared that the wall must be kept “high and impregnable.” And from that moment forward, the wall was turned around. What the Baptists built to protect the GARDEN was reaimed to fence in the GARDENER. What was built to keep government out of the pulpit became a weapon to keep the pulpit out of the public square. The wall that once protected the jailed preacher now gets quoted to silence the free one. That’s not separation. That’s INVERSION. ________________ TEAR DOWN THE COUNTERFEIT So yes — it is time to tear down that wall. Not the one on the southern border. That wall keeps the wilderness OUT. This one fences the garden IN. Not Roger Williams’ wall. Not the wall the Virginia Baptists bled for. HUGO BLACK’S wall — the counterfeit — the one that took a shield built for preachers and turned it into a gag for them. Tear it down. he wall the Virginia Baptists bled for. HUGO BLACK’S wall — the counterfeit — the one that took a shield built for preachers and turned it into a gag for them. Tear it down. And put the real one back up where it belongs. Now hear me clearly. I am FOR the separation of church and state. The ORIGINAL one. I want the government out of the church’s calendar. I want the government out of the church’s pulpit. I want the government out of the church’s pocket. I want no bureaucrat, no agency, no governor, and no judge telling a congregation when it may gather or what its preacher may say. That is the wall Roger Williams drew. That is the wall the Virginia Baptists bled for. That is the wall Jefferson promised the Baptists of Danbury. And that wall was built facing OUTWARD — toward the wilderness — to protect the garden of YAHWEH. The church was never told to leave the public square. The government was told to keep its hands off the church. Learn the difference. Teach the difference. Because a people who forget WHO built the wall will let the wilderness use it as a cage. Tear down the cage. Rebuild the wall. earn the difference. Teach the difference. Because a people who forget WHO built the wall will let the wilderness use it as a cage. Tear down the cage. Rebuild the wall. And Now You Know… THE BEST of the Story. CLASS DISMISSED!!!!

Summary

Professor Toto teaches that the 'wall of separation' was built by persecuted Baptists to keep the government out of the church, not the church out of public life. In colonial Virginia, the Anglican establishment was paid by tobacco levies on all households and dissenting preachers were jailed for preaching without a license. Roger Williams first wrote of a wall protecting the church's garden from the wilderness of the world (1644), and Baptist petitions carried Jefferson's Statute for Religious Freedom in 1786. Jefferson's 1802 Danbury letter, followed two days later by his attendance at John Leland's sermon in the Capitol, shows its meaning. Justice Black's Everson ruling (1947) inverted it.

Source document

Original source document

This teaching is shown above as searchable text so readers can jump directly to matched words.

Open source