No exact match for "thefakepresident.org" in this transcript. This result may have matched scripture references, topics, or other metadata—check sections above.
Title: TOTO TONIGHT: Full Show Script, Tuesday, November 10, 2026: Nobody Can Say He Wasn't Told
Summary: This TOTO TONIGHT script, one week after the 2026 midterm losses, covers the 8-1 Big Bend wall ruling, Trump's BBC suit, Van Jones's online-messaging admission, the Hegseth impeachment vote and the Thune leadership fight. It proposes a $10,000 earned-status immigration penalty as a possible Trump 'deal', recounts the Islamic conquests, and reviews Professor Toto's prediction receipts. The closing monologue argues from Joel 3:2 and William Koenig's record that YAHWEH judges nations that divide His land, and warns President Trump not to oppose Israel's hold on Judea and Samaria.
TOTO TONIGHT
with Professor Toto
Where the Republic Meets the Word
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 | FULL SHOW
SCRIPT
️ SEGMENT 1 — WELCOME
& OPENING
Duration: ~5 minutes
[ COLD OPEN: FREEDOM FREQUENCY THEME —
FULL ]
Good evening, Toto-Town!
Good evening, America.
I'm Professor Toto — the Connoisseur of
Common Sense — and we are ALREADY
moving.
Broadcasting with the Titanium Mic of
Magnanimity from Toto-Town on the Gulf
Coast of Mississippi...
on the FREEDOM FREQUENCY.
ur of
Common Sense — and we are ALREADY
moving.
Broadcasting with the Titanium Mic of
Magnanimity from Toto-Town on the Gulf
Coast of Mississippi...
on the FREEDOM FREQUENCY.
Where Tomorrow's News is TODAY.
Where the Republic Meets the Word.
Now Class — one week after the election,
the country is full of experts.
Every cable host who got it wrong last
Tuesday is back on the air tonight explaining
what happened.
Same tan. Same teleprompter. Same
confidence.
Not here.
In this classroom, we don't grade ourselves
on how good we sound.
We grade ourselves on the RECEIPTS.
What did you say — and when did you say it
— and did it happen?
That's the standard.
FIRST and RIGHT.
grade ourselves
on how good we sound.
We grade ourselves on the RECEIPTS.
What did you say — and when did you say it
— and did it happen?
That's the standard.
FIRST and RIGHT.
TOMORROW IS VETERANS DAY
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: VETERANS DAY — NOVEMBER
11 — THANK YOU ]
But before ONE word of politics tonight...
Tomorrow is November the 11th.
VETERANS DAY.
The eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the
eleventh month — 1918 — the guns of the
Great War fell silent.
And every year since, this nation stops to
say two words to the men and women who
wrote a blank check to the United States of
America...
payable up to and including their lives.
THANK YOU.
Every freedom we're going to exercise in
this classroom tonight —
the freedom to speak...
the freedom to worship...
merica...
payable up to and including their lives.
THANK YOU.
Every freedom we're going to exercise in
this classroom tonight —
the freedom to speak...
the freedom to worship...
the freedom to say the President is right and
the Senate is wrong...
somebody in a uniform PAID for it.
So if you're a veteran listening tonight — this
classroom stands for you.
And if you know one — don't text him
tomorrow.
CALL him.
Shake his hand. Buy his lunch. Look him in
the eye and say it.
"Greater love hath no man than this,
that a man lay down his life for his
friends." — John 15:13
We don't forget. Not in Toto-Town.
So pull your chair up to the desk.
Sharpen the pencil.
Text a friend and tell him the Professor is on.
Because class is in session.
John 15:13
We don't forget. Not in Toto-Town.
So pull your chair up to the desk.
Sharpen the pencil.
Text a friend and tell him the Professor is on.
Because class is in session.
And before we open the books — family
business.
[ TRANSITION STING ]
SEGMENT 2 —
ANNOUNCEMENTS
Duration: ~6 minutes
TOTO FREE PRESS IS A SUBSTACK
BESTSELLER
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: SUBSTACK BESTSELLER —
professortoto.substack.com ]
Class — I have NEWS from the front office of
Toto-Town.
TOTO FREE PRESS — our FREE daily blog —
has just been recognized as a BESTSELLER
on Substack.
Six years ago it was one man, one phone
and one parking lot.
Today — a Substack Bestseller.
That's not MY badge.
That's YOURS.
just been recognized as a BESTSELLER
on Substack.
Six years ago it was one man, one phone
and one parking lot.
Today — a Substack Bestseller.
That's not MY badge.
That's YOURS.
Every one of you who read it, shared it,
printed it out, and argued with your brother-
in-law over it at the dinner table — you did
this.
And if you're not reading yet — it's FREE.
professortoto.substack.com.
TODAY'S T-DROP: THE NEW
GOVERNMENT OF ISRAEL
And you can start TODAY.
Because so many of you are confused about
the new government of Israel.
Who's in. Who's out. What it means for
Jerusalem — and what it means for you.
I wrote today's T-DROP to clear it up.
Plainly. Simply. NO confusion.
[ PRODUCER: INSERT T-DROP TITLE ON SCREEN ]
Read it before you let anybody else tell you
what it means.
ou.
I wrote today's T-DROP to clear it up.
Plainly. Simply. NO confusion.
[ PRODUCER: INSERT T-DROP TITLE ON SCREEN ]
Read it before you let anybody else tell you
what it means.
NEW BOOK — THEY HAD THE
MIDTERMS. NOW IT'S HIS TURN!
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: NEW BOOK RELEASE |
PROFESSOR TOTO ]
And speaking of reading —
THEY HAD THE MIDTERMS. NOW IT'S
HIS TURN!
My newest book is out RIGHT NOW.
The midterms have come and gone.
But what REALLY happened?
Why did YAHWEH allow it?
And what comes next for President Donald J.
Trump — and for the United States of
America?
Not the pundits' answer.
Not the pollsters' answer.
History. Politics. And prophecy.
The midterms were THEIR moment.
But the story is FAR from over.
Paperback. Kindle. Audible.
Search THEY HAD THE MIDTERMS on
Amazon.
Read it. Listen to it. Put it in the hands of
somebody who's discouraged tonight.
FOR PETE'S SAKE
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: FOR PETE'S SAKE — YOUTUBE &
RUMBLE ]
And if you haven't seen my newest video yet
—
FOR PETE'S SAKE.
Republicans — REPUBLICANS — are turning
on Pete Hegseth.
Not CNN. Not the Democrats.
His OWN side.
Why?
I lay it ALL out.
Shared more than 500 times in its first 12
hours.
AKE.
Republicans — REPUBLICANS — are turning
on Pete Hegseth.
Not CNN. Not the Democrats.
His OWN side.
Why?
I lay it ALL out.
Shared more than 500 times in its first 12
hours.
It's on YouTube and Rumble.
Watch it. Share it. Let's make it five
thousand.
THE THANKSGIVING CONVENTION
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: THANKSGIVING CONVENTION —
HEADQUARTERS ]
And Class — mark your calendar.
The Thanksgiving Convention is coming
to our headquarters here on the Gulf Coast
—
November 20th through the 22nd.
Three days.
Teaching. Fellowship. Food. Family.
After the week this country just had — you
need to be in a room full of people who still
know Who holds the future.
Come home to Toto-Town.
Details and registration at
HisComingKingdom.com.
I want to shake your hand.
u
need to be in a room full of people who still
know Who holds the future.
Come home to Toto-Town.
Details and registration at
HisComingKingdom.com.
I want to shake your hand.
[ TRANSITION STING ]
SEGMENT 3 — BREAKING
NEWS & DEEP DIVES
Duration: ~60 minutes
BREAKING: THE WALL GOES UP —
EIGHT TO ONE
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: SUPREME COURT — 8–1 — BIG
BEND ]
We start with a WIN.
Yesterday, the Supreme Court of the United
States cleared the way for President Trump
to RESUME building the wall in the Big Bend
region of Texas.
A federal judge in El Paso had stopped the
bulldozers.
The Court lifted her order.
Three hundred forty-one miles.
Bulldozers back on.
The vote?
EIGHT to ONE.
Now write that number down, Class.
EIGHT.
Do you know what eight means?
It means Sonia Sotomayor voted to let the
wall go up.
It means Elena Kagan voted to let the wall
go up.
Only ONE justice said no.
Ketanji Brown Jackson.
And did she write an opinion?
Did she give the American people one single
reason?
No.
One line: "JUSTICE JACKSON would deny the
application."
That's it.
Ketanji Brown Jackson.
And did she write an opinion?
Did she give the American people one single
reason?
No.
One line: "JUSTICE JACKSON would deny the
application."
That's it.
When Sotomayor and Kagan won't stand
with you — you're not on the bench
anymore.
You're on an ISLAND.
And the President's Solicitor General said it
best:
"We just won 8–1."
Now — this is an emergency order. The
lawsuit keeps going.
But the bulldozers don't have to wait for it.
FINISH. THE. WALL.
BREAKING: TRUMP BEATS THE BBC IN
COURT
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: TRUMP TRUTH SOCIAL — BBC
RULING ]
And the winning didn't stop at the border.
Today — Tuesday — a federal judge in
Florida looked at the British Broadcasting
Corporation and said: NOT SO FAST.
Remember the story, Class.
winning didn't stop at the border.
Today — Tuesday — a federal judge in
Florida looked at the British Broadcasting
Corporation and said: NOT SO FAST.
Remember the story, Class.
One week before the 2024 election, the BBC
ran a Panorama documentary.
They took President Trump's January 6th
speech...
took a line from the top...
took a line from nearly an hour later...
and SPLICED them together.
Made it sound like he told the crowd to
march on the Capitol and "fight like hell."
He never said it that way.
Not once.
The BBC got caught.
Their own internal memo blew the whistle.
Their top executives walked out the door.
They APOLOGIZED.
And then they said — "Sorry... but you can't
sue us."
e.
The BBC got caught.
Their own internal memo blew the whistle.
Their top executives walked out the door.
They APOLOGIZED.
And then they said — "Sorry... but you can't
sue us."
So the President sued anyway. Ten. Billion.
Dollars.
The BBC ran to court and begged the judge
to throw it out.
Today, Judge Jeffrey Kuntz said NO.
The defamation case goes FORWARD.
And listen to what the court said, as the
President posted it:
"Here, the news entity created the
story. BBC admitted as much by
confirming it had edited a video to
make it appear as though President
Trump made a statement he never
made."
Did you hear that?
The news entity CREATED the story.
That's not Professor Toto talking.
That's a federal court.
pear as though President
Trump made a statement he never
made."
Did you hear that?
The news entity CREATED the story.
That's not Professor Toto talking.
That's a federal court.
Now — to be precise — the judge did toss
one narrower claim under Florida's trade-
practices law.
But the big one — the DEFAMATION claim —
the ten-billion-dollar claim — that one LIVES.
And it heads toward trial.
Put this right next to what we're about to
talk about.
The Founders said the people would be "the
dupes of pretended patriots."
Well, here's a pretended news network —
caught red-handed — editing a President's
words to deceive the voters a week before
an election.
For years they called him a liar.
Now a judge says THEY made it up.
CONGRATULATIONS, PRESIDENT
TRUMP.
And BBC — see you in court.
deceive the voters a week before
an election.
For years they called him a liar.
Now a judge says THEY made it up.
CONGRATULATIONS, PRESIDENT
TRUMP.
And BBC — see you in court.
DEEP DIVE: THE FOUNDERS SAW YOU
COMING
[ MUSIC BED: LOW ]
Now Class — I want to go deep.
Because everybody wants to know what
happened last Tuesday night.
And I found the answer in a place nobody's
looking.
Philadelphia.
1787.
I've been watching The American
Experiment on Netflix. Five episodes.
And episodes four and five will open your
eyes.
PART ONE — THE MEN IN THE HOT
ROOM
Summer of 1787.
Fifty-five men locked in a hot room.
No air conditioning.
lix. Five episodes.
And episodes four and five will open your
eyes.
PART ONE — THE MEN IN THE HOT
ROOM
Summer of 1787.
Fifty-five men locked in a hot room.
No air conditioning.
Windows shut so nobody outside could
eavesdrop.
And James Madison sat up front — missed
hardly a day — writing it all down.
And the thing they argued about, over and
over, wasn't taxes.
It was YOU.
Could the ordinary voter be trusted to
choose his own rulers?
On May 31st, 1787, a delegate from
Massachusetts named Elbridge Gerry stood
up.
And Madison wrote down what he said:
"The evils we experience flow from the
excess of democracy. The people do
not want virtue, but are the dupes of
pretended patriots."
Now listen carefully — because the history
teachers get this wrong.
In 1787, "want" meant LACK.
cracy. The people do
not want virtue, but are the dupes of
pretended patriots."
Now listen carefully — because the history
teachers get this wrong.
In 1787, "want" meant LACK.
Gerry did NOT say the people had no virtue.
He said the people HAVE virtue —
but they are DUPES.
Good people.
Fooled.
Fooled by "pretended patriots."
That's a signer of the Declaration of
Independence talking.
And his fear was simple:
the crowd will always be bought with
something shiny TODAY —
and pay for it with something precious
TOMORROW.
PART TWO — THE FILTERS
So what did the Founders do?
They built FILTERS into the Republic.
The Electoral College for the presidency.
And the Senate —
Class, the Senate wasn't elected by you AT
ALL.
State legislatures chose your senators for
the first 124 years of this country —
until the Seventeenth Amendment in 1913.
The House was the people's chamber.
Hot-blooded. Two-year terms.
Let the people vent THERE.
But the Senate was supposed to be the
elders at the gate.
Six-year terms.
Cooler heads.
Men who could outlast the temper of the
moment.
Do you see it?
The Founders built a Republic designed to
survive the exact thing that happened last
Tuesday night:
ooler heads.
Men who could outlast the temper of the
moment.
Do you see it?
The Founders built a Republic designed to
survive the exact thing that happened last
Tuesday night:
a nation voting its gas tank instead of
its grandchildren.
PART THREE — THE PRETENDED
PATRIOTS
And now — the "pretended patriots."
Last Thursday, Van Jones sat down on CNN
with Kaitlan Collins.
And he grinned.
And he said: "Now it can be told."
He said the Democrats ran something called
the American Accountability Network.
His words — "tens of thousands of online
humans, not bots, coordinated to make the
affordability message a winning message
online."
And then he bragged about the reach.
Thirty-two and a half million people on
Instagram — every day.
Eighty-eight point eight million on X — every
day.
winning message
online."
And then he bragged about the reach.
Thirty-two and a half million people on
Instagram — every day.
Eighty-eight point eight million on X — every
day.
One hundred eighty-five million on Facebook
— EVERY DAY.
"The Republicans never figured out what we
were doing."
And then the line that should make your
blood run cold:
"Don't get mad at me. I was given
permission to reveal this."
PERMISSION.
From whom, Van?
[ DRAMATIC PAUSE ]
Elbridge Gerry warned you about these
people two hundred and thirty-nine years
ago.
PART FOUR — LET ME GIVE YOU THE
RECEIPTS
Because they don't think you can find the
truth about the economy on your own.
So let me hand it to you.
ed and thirty-nine years
ago.
PART FOUR — LET ME GIVE YOU THE
RECEIPTS
Because they don't think you can find the
truth about the economy on your own.
So let me hand it to you.
■ 165,000 new jobs in October. The
experts guessed about 60,000.
Unemployment fell to 4.1%.
■ The poverty rate: 10.2% — the LOWEST
ever recorded.
■ Median household income: $87,460 —
the HIGHEST since the government
started counting in 1967.
■ The economy grew at 3.4% last quarter
— and the Atlanta Fed is tracking about
the same pace right now.
■ The Dow closed at 53,356 the day after
the election — about TWENTY
THOUSAND points higher than at the
2022 midterms.
And in 2022?
Inflation had just hit 9.1% — the worst in
forty years.
And the media told you Joe Biden was doing
a GREAT job.
This year — the opposite.
an at the
2022 midterms.
And in 2022?
Inflation had just hit 9.1% — the worst in
forty years.
And the media told you Joe Biden was doing
a GREAT job.
This year — the opposite.
Record income. Record-low poverty.
And they told you the sky was falling.
Same media.
Opposite story.
And Van Jones just told you how they did it.
Now — they'll say, "Professor, people FELT it
at the pump."
Yes, they did. I'll show you what happened at
the pump in a minute.
But here's the lesson of the Deep Dive.
They don't think you're too dumb, Class.
They think you're too DUPED.
And Elbridge Gerry said it in 1787:
the people don't lack virtue.
They're just easy to fool —
by pretended patriots.
Don't be one of them.
mb, Class.
They think you're too DUPED.
And Elbridge Gerry said it in 1787:
the people don't lack virtue.
They're just easy to fool —
by pretended patriots.
Don't be one of them.
BREAKING: AND SNAP — GAS PRICES
FALL
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: AAA NATIONAL AVERAGE —
$4.02 ]
And SNAP — just like that.
The day AFTER the midterms, oil drops more
than eight percent in a single day.
Below ninety dollars a barrel for the first
time since September.
Gas falls twelve cents in ONE week.
Now sitting at four-oh-two — and dropping.
Where was THIS two weeks ago —
when you were standing at the pump
deciding how to vote?
You can't make this stuff up.
Remember what I just told you —
a nation voting its gas tank instead of its
grandchildren.
They knew EXACTLY where you'd be looking.
g how to vote?
You can't make this stuff up.
Remember what I just told you —
a nation voting its gas tank instead of its
grandchildren.
They knew EXACTLY where you'd be looking.
At the pump.
BREAKING: THE SENATE MOVES TO
BUILD — 73 TO 25
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: SENATE — 73–25 — AMERICAN
AFFORDABILITY AND JOBS ACT ]
And speaking of affordability —
yesterday the Senate voted 73 to 25 to
advance a Trump-backed bill called — are
you ready for this —
the American AFFORDABILITY and Jobs
Act.
AFFORDABILITY.
Remember that word?
Van Jones' army spent six months screaming
it at you.
Well — here's an actual affordability bill.
Slashing red tape.
Unleashing American energy.
Building pipelines.
r that word?
Van Jones' army spent six months screaming
it at you.
Well — here's an actual affordability bill.
Slashing red tape.
Unleashing American energy.
Building pipelines.
Lowering costs for families.
Seventy-three senators. Republicans AND
Democrats.
So I have one question for the new
Democrat majority:
you RAN on affordability.
Now we find out if you'll VOTE for it.
The clock is ticking — they have to get it
done before the new Congress takes over in
January.
Finish it.
Get it to President Trump's desk.
America is ready to BUILD again!
BREAKING: HEGSETH SURVIVES — BY
SEVEN VOTES
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: BREAKING — HOUSE BLOCKS
HEGSETH IMPEACHMENT — 211–204 ]
And Class — this one came down to the wire
tonight.
again!
BREAKING: HEGSETH SURVIVES — BY
SEVEN VOTES
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: BREAKING — HOUSE BLOCKS
HEGSETH IMPEACHMENT — 211–204 ]
And Class — this one came down to the wire
tonight.
The House just voted to BLOCK the
impeachment of Secretary of War Pete
Hegseth.
The vote?
Two hundred eleven to two hundred
four.
SEVEN votes.
Flip FOUR Republicans — and Pete Hegseth
gets impeached tonight.
That's how close it was.
And who brought it?
Not a Democrat.
A REPUBLICAN. Thomas Massie of Kentucky.
The lone Republican who stood with every
single Democrat in that chamber.
A man who lost his own primary — and is on
his way out the door in January.
Hegseth called it what it was: a "political
spectacle."
with every
single Democrat in that chamber.
A man who lost his own primary — and is on
his way out the door in January.
Hegseth called it what it was: a "political
spectacle."
But don't celebrate too long.
Hakeem Jeffries walked out of that chamber
and said: "This is not the end."
He means it.
In January, the gavel changes hands.
And the people who couldn't get it done
tonight —
will have the votes to try again.
This is EXACTLY what I warned you about in
FOR PETE'S SAKE.
When Republicans start turning on Pete
Hegseth —
the Democrats don't need to beat him.
They just need to wait.
DEEP DIVE: THEIR PLAN FOR 2028 —
AND WHY THUNE MUST GO
Now — you keep asking me the same
question.
Pete
Hegseth —
the Democrats don't need to beat him.
They just need to wait.
DEEP DIVE: THEIR PLAN FOR 2028 —
AND WHY THUNE MUST GO
Now — you keep asking me the same
question.
"Professor, how can people be so BLIND that
an ILLEGAL immigrant is somehow not
'illegal'?"
It's not something in the water, Class.
It's something on the SCREEN.
Say "undocumented" a million times a day —
and "illegal" starts to sound like a slur.
They didn't DRUG you.
They DRILLED you.
And now I want you to see where it's
headed.
Not my theory.
THEIR playbook.
[ PLAY VIDEO: THE 2028 PLAN ]
[ PRODUCER: ON-SCREEN CREDIT FOR SPEAKER ]
Did you hear it?
Step one — fill the country.
Step two — fill the rolls.
.
Not my theory.
THEIR playbook.
[ PLAY VIDEO: THE 2028 PLAN ]
[ PRODUCER: ON-SCREEN CREDIT FOR SPEAKER ]
Did you hear it?
Step one — fill the country.
Step two — fill the rolls.
Step three — let friendly judges lock the
door so nobody can check them.
Step four — run it in the midterms and see if
anybody notices.
Step five — 2028. The House. The Senate.
The White House.
Step six — pack the Court.
And then, Class, the Constitution becomes a
museum piece.
Under glass.
Pretty to look at —
and POWERLESS.
Now ask yourself — who had the power to
stop it?
One man held the Senate gavel.
One man could have put the SAVE America
Act on the floor and made every senator
vote in broad daylight.
And he didn't.
had the power to
stop it?
One man held the Senate gavel.
One man could have put the SAVE America
Act on the floor and made every senator
vote in broad daylight.
And he didn't.
John Thune.
I don't care how nice he is.
I don't care how many years he's served.
A general who won't fight doesn't get to
keep his stars.
Remember the Founders' Senate — the
elders at the GATE?
Thune left the gate OPEN.
Republicans — if you want to exist in 2029,
you need a new leader.
Not next year.
NOW.
And Class — it's already starting.
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: THE SEVEN — JOHNSON • LEE •
SCOTT • KENNEDY • McCORMICK • BANKS •
BUDD ]
JUST IN.
Seven Republican senators moved to STOP
Thune's coronation as minority leader.
SHOW GRAPHIC: THE SEVEN — JOHNSON • LEE •
SCOTT • KENNEDY • McCORMICK • BANKS •
BUDD ]
JUST IN.
Seven Republican senators moved to STOP
Thune's coronation as minority leader.
Ron Johnson of Wisconsin.
Mike Lee of Utah.
Rick Scott of Florida.
John Kennedy of Louisiana.
Dave McCormick of Pennsylvania.
Jim Banks of Indiana.
Ted Budd of North Carolina.
Ron Johnson wrote the letter — called last
Tuesday "a stunning defeat."
And then he said this:
"If you hold the election, I'll leave the room."
THAT'S a senator.
And here's what happened TODAY.
This morning they walked into that closed-
door room to crown John Thune —
and they walked OUT without a decision.
Two hours. Nothing.
a senator.
And here's what happened TODAY.
This morning they walked into that closed-
door room to crown John Thune —
and they walked OUT without a decision.
Two hours. Nothing.
Then they came back this afternoon.
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: BREAKING — THUNE REELECTED
• 15 VOTED TO DELAY ]
BREAKING: John Thune REMAINS Senate
Republican leader.
By acclamation. No challenger.
But Class — don't let them hide the number.
Before they crowned him, they voted on
whether to wait.
Thirty-one to FIFTEEN.
This morning it was seven.
By this afternoon — FIFTEEN Republican
senators voted NOT to hand him the crown.
That's a THIRD of the next Republican
conference.
And Ron Johnson?
He told them, "If you hold the election, I'll
leave the room."
They held it.
voted NOT to hand him the crown.
That's a THIRD of the next Republican
conference.
And Ron Johnson?
He told them, "If you hold the election, I'll
leave the room."
They held it.
He LEFT the room.
A man who keeps his word — in Washington.
Write that down. You won't see it often.
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: BREAKING — HOUSE GOP PICKS
JIM JORDAN ]
Now look at the other side of the Capitol.
The HOUSE got the message.
House Republicans picked Jim Jordan as
their next leader.
Over Steve Scalise.
Jim Jordan — fighter. Close Trump ally. The
man who's been kicking down doors in
Washington for twenty years.
The House looked at the worst election night
in decades and said:
we need FRESH leadership.
Not the same faces.
Not the same plan.
Not the same results.
ington for twenty years.
The House looked at the worst election night
in decades and said:
we need FRESH leadership.
Not the same faces.
Not the same plan.
Not the same results.
The House chose a FIGHTER.
The Senate chose the SAME MAN.
Same faces. Same plan.
So you tell me what results to expect.
Fifteen senators put him on notice today.
Every Republican senator should have been
standing with them.
John Thune has failed as leader.
You don't reward a man for his failures.
THUNE MUST GO.
DEEP DIVE: THE ART OF THE DEAL — I
SEE WHAT HE'S DOING
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: "TOO TOUGH" — THE ART OF
THE DEAL ]
Now — I just showed you THEIR plan for
2028.
Now let me show you what I believe OUR
President may be doing.
WHAT HE'S DOING
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: "TOO TOUGH" — THE ART OF
THE DEAL ]
Now — I just showed you THEIR plan for
2028.
Now let me show you what I believe OUR
President may be doing.
Because everybody is upset this week — and
I mean EVERYBODY — about one thing
President Trump said.
And I believe I see what he's doing.
Folks, tonight I want to have a serious
conversation with you about immigration,
Donald Trump, the future of America, and
something that has been turning over in my
mind since the midterm elections.
And I want you to hear me all the way
through before you make up your mind.
Because I am going to suggest something
tonight that might surprise some of my
fellow MAGA Republicans.
I am a diehard MAGA Republican.
I believe in national sovereignty. I believe in
borders. I believe in the rule of law. And I
believe that when a nation loses control of
who enters its territory, who resides within
its borders, and who becomes part of its
national family, that nation places its very
future in jeopardy.
nation loses control of
who enters its territory, who resides within
its borders, and who becomes part of its
national family, that nation places its very
future in jeopardy.
History gives us plenty of examples of
empires weakened by failures of
governance, internal division, economic
instability, and the inability to maintain
control of their territories.
And I believe uncontrolled immigration can
become part of that danger.
That is why I supported President Donald
Trump's tough immigration policies.
I supported removing people who entered
our country illegally.
I supported the president when he promised
to restore law and order to our borders.
And I have not abandoned those convictions
tonight.
But something has happened that has
caused me to examine this question from
another angle.
And I wonder whether President Trump
himself may be examining it from another
angle as well.
hing has happened that has
caused me to examine this question from
another angle.
And I wonder whether President Trump
himself may be examining it from another
angle as well.
Or perhaps—and this is what I really want
you to consider—perhaps Donald Trump has
been playing a much longer game than any
of us realized.
THE NIGHT THAT CHANGED MY
THINKING
When I began examining the political
reaction to the administration's immigration
enforcement policies, particularly the
reaction in Texas, something occurred to
me.
Texas is not just another state.
Texas is one of the great electoral prizes in
American politics.
It carries 40 electoral votes.
And in a presidential election, those 40
electoral votes can dramatically alter the
electoral map.
Now, I am not suggesting that we ought to
abandon our principles merely because a
policy becomes politically difficult.
ectoral votes can dramatically alter the
electoral map.
Now, I am not suggesting that we ought to
abandon our principles merely because a
policy becomes politically difficult.
Perish the thought!
But I am suggesting that responsible political
leadership must recognize the difference
between an objective and the methods used
to accomplish that objective.
The objective is a secure America.
The objective is a nation governed by laws.
The objective is an immigration system that
respects American sovereignty.
But must the method always be the
deportation of every single person who
entered this country illegally?
That is the question I began asking myself.
And then — Sunday night — on 60 Minutes
— I heard the President of the United States
say it out loud.
[ PLAY VIDEO: PRESIDENT TRUMP — 60 MINUTES
— "TOO TOUGH" ]
"I think it might be too tough, yeah."
— on 60 Minutes
— I heard the President of the United States
say it out loud.
[ PLAY VIDEO: PRESIDENT TRUMP — 60 MINUTES
— "TOO TOUGH" ]
"I think it might be too tough, yeah."
Too tough — on people who've been here
ten, fifteen years, working, raising families,
no serious crimes.
He said they're "good people working in a
landscaping company, or working in a hotel."
And he said a deal with the Democrats is —
his word — "doable."
And I thought to myself:
Wait just a minute.
What exactly are we witnessing here?
Is this a president retreating from his
promises?
Is this a president reacting to political
pressure?
Or is something much bigger happening?
THE MAN WHO WROTE THE ART OF
THE DEAL
Ladies and gentlemen, we are talking about
Donald John Trump.
dent reacting to political
pressure?
Or is something much bigger happening?
THE MAN WHO WROTE THE ART OF
THE DEAL
Ladies and gentlemen, we are talking about
Donald John Trump.
A man who built his public identity around
negotiating.
A man whose name became synonymous
with The Art of the Deal.
And anybody who understands aggressive
negotiation knows that you do not
necessarily begin by asking for the minimum
you are willing to accept.
You establish your strongest position.
You make your opening demand.
You create leverage.
You make certain that the other side
understands that you are serious.
And then you negotiate.
Sometimes you shoot for the moon, knowing
that the final agreement may land
somewhere among the stars.
Now, I want to be very precise about what I
am saying tonight.
egotiate.
Sometimes you shoot for the moon, knowing
that the final agreement may land
somewhere among the stars.
Now, I want to be very precise about what I
am saying tonight.
I do not know what Donald Trump has been
thinking privately.
I have not been sitting in the Oval Office
listening to his conversations.
I cannot tell you that this has been his plan
from the beginning.
But I want to put a possibility before you.
What if Donald Trump understood that
comprehensive immigration reform would
never happen until Washington was forced
to confront the consequences of doing
nothing?
What if he believed that the only way to
bring Democrats to the negotiating table
was to demonstrate that the deportation
machinery of the federal government was
not merely a campaign slogan?
What if the aggressive enforcement was
designed not only to remove people
unlawfully present, but also to create the
leverage necessary to negotiate something
much larger?
n?
What if the aggressive enforcement was
designed not only to remove people
unlawfully present, but also to create the
leverage necessary to negotiate something
much larger?
And what if the destination was never simply
mass deportation?
What if the destination was a comprehensive
immigration settlement?
Oh, the political implications of such a
possibility!
AND THEN THERE IS STEPHEN MILLER
Now, everybody wants to point to Stephen
Miller.
They say, Professor Toto, look at Stephen
Miller!
Trump just made him WHITE HOUSE CHIEF
OF STAFF!
Surely that proves President Trump has no
intention of moderating his immigration
policies.
Well, perhaps it does.
But let me ask you something.
If Donald Trump were preparing for the
biggest immigration negotiation in modern
n of moderating his immigration
policies.
Well, perhaps it does.
But let me ask you something.
If Donald Trump were preparing for the
biggest immigration negotiation in modern
American history, would he really begin by
announcing that his administration was no
longer serious about enforcement?
Would he voluntarily surrender his leverage?
Would he tell the Democrats that they had
nothing left to fear from continued
deportations?
Why would he do that?
Now look at the TIMING, Class.
Friday — Trump names Stephen Miller, the
architect of the crackdown, his chief of staff.
Sunday — Trump goes on 60 Minutes and
says a deal is "doable."
And who will sit across the table from
Congress as the President's principal
negotiator?
Stephen Miller.
Perhaps Stephen Miller is exactly what he
appears to be: a committed advocate of
aggressive immigration enforcement.
s as the President's principal
negotiator?
Stephen Miller.
Perhaps Stephen Miller is exactly what he
appears to be: a committed advocate of
aggressive immigration enforcement.
But perhaps his presence also serves a
negotiating purpose.
Perhaps it tells Congress that the
administration remains fully prepared to
continue its enforcement policies unless a
legislative agreement can be reached.
Do you see the distinction?
You can be willing to negotiate without
surrendering the pressure that makes
negotiation possible.
You can extend one hand toward an
agreement while keeping the other hand
firmly on the enforcement mechanisms
already established.
That is not proof of some secret master plan.
But it is a serious possibility worth
examining.
And the history of Donald Trump gives us a
reason to ask the question.
Because in 2018, his administration was
already willing to consider a pathway to
ility worth
examining.
And the history of Donald Trump gives us a
reason to ask the question.
Because in 2018, his administration was
already willing to consider a pathway to
citizenship for approximately 1.8 million
people under a proposed immigration
compromise, provided Congress also
delivered substantial border-security and
immigration changes.
So the idea that Donald Trump could support
some form of legalization in exchange for
stronger enforcement is not something I
have invented tonight.
His own administration previously put such
an exchange on the table.
And that brings me to the proposal I want to
discuss with you.
HAVE WE BEEN RIGHT AND WRONG
AT THE SAME TIME?
Now, folks, I want to talk to my conservative
friends.
Because I am one of you.
And I understand the argument.
We say, they broke the law!
EEN RIGHT AND WRONG
AT THE SAME TIME?
Now, folks, I want to talk to my conservative
friends.
Because I am one of you.
And I understand the argument.
We say, they broke the law!
And that is true.
We say, if Americans break the law, there
are consequences!
And that is true.
We say, nobody should be rewarded for
entering our country illegally!
And I understand that argument.
But here is where I believe we need to think
more carefully.
Not every violation of the law carries the
same punishment.
Not every offense requires imprisonment.
Not every legal violation results in a family
being permanently separated.
Our legal system recognizes different
offenses, different circumstances, different
degrees of responsibility, and different
penalties.
Consider trespassing.
anently separated.
Our legal system recognizes different
offenses, different circumstances, different
degrees of responsibility, and different
penalties.
Consider trespassing.
In many circumstances, trespassing is
punishable by a fine rather than a lengthy
prison sentence.
Now, improper entry into the United States
is not technically the same offense as
ordinary trespassing.
Federal immigration law has its own
provisions, including criminal penalties for
improper entry and separate civil
consequences for unlawful presence.
I understand that distinction.
But my larger point remains.
The existence of a legal violation does
not mean that deportation must be the
only consequence Congress is
permitted to consider.
Congress has the authority to establish
immigration laws, define eligibility for lawful
status, and create penalties and procedures
for resolving violations.
tted to consider.
Congress has the authority to establish
immigration laws, define eligibility for lawful
status, and create penalties and procedures
for resolving violations.
So why can we not have a serious national
discussion about imposing a substantial
financial penalty on certain people who
entered illegally, while establishing a lawful
process through which they can earn
permission to remain?
Why must the conversation always be
reduced to two extremes?
Deport everybody!
Or let everybody stay!
What if there is another possibility?
What if we can enforce the law, impose
accountability, protect American
sovereignty, and still recognize the humanity
of the people involved?
LET ME INTRODUCE YOU TO A $10,000
IDEA
Suppose Congress and President Trump sat
down and negotiated a comprehensive
immigration reform bill.
humanity
of the people involved?
LET ME INTRODUCE YOU TO A $10,000
IDEA
Suppose Congress and President Trump sat
down and negotiated a comprehensive
immigration reform bill.
And suppose that legislation established a
one-time opportunity for qualifying
undocumented immigrants who were
already living in the United States before a
fixed cutoff date.
Not an open invitation to the rest of the
world.
Not a promise that anybody who crosses the
border tomorrow will receive the same
opportunity.
A defined program for people already here.
And suppose that program required every
applicant to come forward voluntarily.
Register with the federal government.
Establish their identity.
Undergo criminal background checks.
Disclose their immigration history.
Comply with tax laws.
Demonstrate that they meet the eligibility
requirements.
Establish their identity.
Undergo criminal background checks.
Disclose their immigration history.
Comply with tax laws.
Demonstrate that they meet the eligibility
requirements.
And then pay a substantial financial penalty.
Let's say $10,000.
Ten thousand dollars!
Not ten dollars.
Not a slap on the wrist.
Ten thousand dollars in accountability for
violating our immigration laws.
Now, I am not saying every family could
write a check tomorrow morning.
Of course not.
So perhaps Congress establishes a
structured payment program.
Perhaps there are deadlines.
Perhaps there are monthly payments.
Perhaps there are carefully defined
provisions for genuine financial hardship.
But the principle would remain.
There is a price attached to the violation.
are monthly payments.
Perhaps there are carefully defined
provisions for genuine financial hardship.
But the principle would remain.
There is a price attached to the violation.
There is an acknowledgment that the law
was broken.
And there is a defined process for resolving
that violation.
In exchange, qualified applicants could
receive conditional legal permission to
remain and work while they satisfy the
requirements.
They could remain with their families.
They could continue contributing to the
economy.
They could come out of the shadows.
And when they successfully completed the
process, they could become eligible for a
legal status established by Congress.
Now, whether that status should be
permanent residency, a renewable work
authorization, or some other lawful category
is a question the legislation would have to
answer.
ess.
Now, whether that status should be
permanent residency, a renewable work
authorization, or some other lawful category
is a question the legislation would have to
answer.
But imagine the difference between a
system in which millions of people remain
outside lawful immigration status and one in
which qualifying individuals are registered,
screened, working legally, and subject to
enforceable requirements.
That is a conversation worth having.
BUT PROFESSOR TOTO, THAT'S
AMNESTY!
Oh, I can hear some of you already!
AMNESTY! AMNESTY!
And I understand why that word creates
such a strong reaction.
But before we start throwing words around,
let's determine exactly what we mean.
If by amnesty you mean any legislation that
allows someone who violated immigration
law to obtain lawful status, then yes, some
people will call this amnesty.
And they have a definitional argument for
doing so.
on that
allows someone who violated immigration
law to obtain lawful status, then yes, some
people will call this amnesty.
And they have a definitional argument for
doing so.
But if by amnesty you mean simply wiping
away the violation, requiring no
accountability, imposing no financial
consequences, and granting unconditional
legal status, then that is not what I am
proposing.
I am proposing something different.
EARNED LEGAL STATUS THROUGH
ACCOUNTABILITY.
You violated the law?
Then acknowledge the violation.
You want permission to remain in the United
States?
Then meet the requirements established by
Congress.
You want to work legally?
Then register, establish your identity, and
satisfy the government's conditions.
You want an opportunity to remain with your
family?
hed by
Congress.
You want to work legally?
Then register, establish your identity, and
satisfy the government's conditions.
You want an opportunity to remain with your
family?
Then accept the financial penalty and
comply with the program.
And if you refuse?
If you deliberately defraud the system?
If you commit disqualifying serious crimes?
If you refuse to comply with the lawful
requirements?
Then you remain subject to the
consequences established by immigration
law, including removal where legally
applicable.
That is not an unconditional pardon.
That is an accountability system.
And notice what it does to THEIR plan for
2028 — the plan I just showed you.
Legal status is NOT citizenship.
It is NOT a ballot.
Registered. Fingerprinted. Background-
checked. Paying a penalty.
does to THEIR plan for
2028 — the plan I just showed you.
Legal status is NOT citizenship.
It is NOT a ballot.
Registered. Fingerprinted. Background-
checked. Paying a penalty.
And OFF the voter rolls.
You want to stop them from filling the rolls?
Bring every one of them into the light —
where we can SEE them.
And I believe the American people deserve
an opportunity to consider the difference.
THE HUMANITY OF THE AMERICAN
PEOPLE
Now, here is where this issue becomes
deeply personal.
I want you to imagine a man who entered
the United States illegally twenty years ago.
He was wrong to do so.
Let's establish that immediately.
But over those twenty years, he married.
He worked.
He raised children.
He became part of a community.
twenty years ago.
He was wrong to do so.
Let's establish that immediately.
But over those twenty years, he married.
He worked.
He raised children.
He became part of a community.
Perhaps his children were born here and are
American citizens.
Perhaps he has never committed a serious
criminal offense.
And now, twenty years later, the federal
government comes to remove him.
The government may have the legal
authority to do so.
But I want you to consider the human
consequences.
What happens to his children?
What happens to his wife?
What happens to the family that depends
upon his income?
And what happens to the American citizens
living in that household?
Because that is another part of this
discussion that cannot be ignored.
We are not talking exclusively about the
people who violated immigration law.
living in that household?
Because that is another part of this
discussion that cannot be ignored.
We are not talking exclusively about the
people who violated immigration law.
We are also talking about millions of people
who possess lawful status, including
American-born children, whose families may
be directly affected.
Now, does having a family erase an
immigration violation?
No.
Does working hard automatically create a
legal right to remain?
No.
But should those circumstances be
completely irrelevant when Congress
decides what penalties and remedies our
laws should provide?
I do not believe they should.
And I suspect that many Americans who
support strong border enforcement also
recognize a difference between a dangerous
criminal and a longtime resident who has
worked, raised a family, and otherwise
obeyed the law.
port strong border enforcement also
recognize a difference between a dangerous
criminal and a longtime resident who has
worked, raised a family, and otherwise
obeyed the law.
That distinction does not eliminate the need
for enforcement.
It raises the question of how enforcement
ought to be structured.
And this is where I began to wonder whether
the American people might ultimately
demand something more complicated than
the slogans coming from Washington.
YOU CANNOT DEPORT YOUR WAY OUT
OF EVERY PROBLEM
Ladies and gentlemen, the United States has
an enormous undocumented population.
Estimates for 2024 placed that population at
approximately 15.8 million.
Think about the scale of that number.
Now imagine attempting to remove every
single person.
The manpower.
The detention facilities.
The immigration courts.
imately 15.8 million.
Think about the scale of that number.
Now imagine attempting to remove every
single person.
The manpower.
The detention facilities.
The immigration courts.
The transportation.
The costs.
The legal challenges.
The impact upon employers and
communities.
And, yes, the family separations.
There is a difference between possessing the
legal authority to enforce a policy and
determining whether its universal
implementation is practical, affordable, and
acceptable to the public.
And I believe this is a question that
Americans, including conservative
Americans, will increasingly have to
confront.
Because when people hear the words mass
deportation, they may imagine violent
criminals being taken off the streets.
But when they see a mother separated from
her children, or a father removed from a
household where his children are American
ne violent
criminals being taken off the streets.
But when they see a mother separated from
her children, or a father removed from a
household where his children are American
citizens, the issue becomes more
complicated.
That is not necessarily hypocrisy.
That may be the American conscience
wrestling with two principles at the same
time.
We believe in law.
And we believe in humanity.
We believe in borders.
And we believe in families.
We believe wrongdoing should carry
consequences.
And we also believe the punishment ought
to be proportionate to the circumstances.
Why must we pretend that these principles
cannot coexist?
THE REPUBLICAN PARTY MUST
UNDERSTAND TEXAS
Now, let's talk politics.
ought
to be proportionate to the circumstances.
Why must we pretend that these principles
cannot coexist?
THE REPUBLICAN PARTY MUST
UNDERSTAND TEXAS
Now, let's talk politics.
Texas carries 40 electoral votes.
Forty!
That makes Texas one of the most
consequential states in presidential politics.
And as we look toward 2028, Republicans
and Democrats alike will be examining what
happened in Texas during the midterms.
They will be examining turnout.
They will be examining Hispanic voters.
They will be examining suburban voters.
They will be examining how immigration
enforcement affected public opinion.
Now, I am not going to pretend that every
Hispanic voter thinks alike.
They do not.
Nor am I going to suggest that the election
results can be explained by one issue alone.
But the political reaction to immigration
enforcement deserves serious examination.
ot.
Nor am I going to suggest that the election
results can be explained by one issue alone.
But the political reaction to immigration
enforcement deserves serious examination.
Because an administration can win support
for securing the border while simultaneously
generating opposition to particular
enforcement methods.
Those are not contradictory reactions.
A voter may support deporting dangerous
criminals while opposing the removal of a
longtime resident with American-born
children.
And a voter may favor a lawful path for
certain existing residents while demanding
that future unauthorized entries be
prevented.
The American electorate is not always as
simple as the political slogans we hear.
And I wonder whether Donald Trump
understands that better than some of his
own supporters.
REMEMBER RONALD REAGAN!
Now, I want to remind my Republican friends
of something.
r.
And I wonder whether Donald Trump
understands that better than some of his
own supporters.
REMEMBER RONALD REAGAN!
Now, I want to remind my Republican friends
of something.
In 1986, President Ronald Reagan signed the
Immigration Reform and Control Act.
And that legislation combined several major
ideas.
It included legalization provisions for certain
undocumented immigrants.
It established employer sanctions for
knowingly hiring unauthorized workers.
And it attempted to strengthen immigration
enforcement.
Ronald Reagan!
The conservative president whose legacy
Republicans have celebrated for
generations.
Now, did that legislation permanently solve
America's immigration problem?
Obviously not.
We are still debating immigration reform
forty years later.
lebrated for
generations.
Now, did that legislation permanently solve
America's immigration problem?
Obviously not.
We are still debating immigration reform
forty years later.
And that history teaches us something
important.
A legalization program without durable
enforcement mechanisms cannot, by itself,
guarantee that the same problem will not
develop again.
So if Congress considers another
comprehensive immigration settlement, it
must learn from 1986.
It must establish clear eligibility dates.
It must enforce the laws governing future
entry.
It must address unlawful employment.
It must provide workable legal immigration
procedures.
And it must define what happens to people
who refuse to comply.
Otherwise, we may find ourselves having
this same conversation another forty years
from now.
ation
procedures.
And it must define what happens to people
who refuse to comply.
Otherwise, we may find ourselves having
this same conversation another forty years
from now.
But Reagan's example establishes one
important historical fact.
The idea of combining legalization with
immigration enforcement has existed within
Republican policymaking before.
And Donald Trump himself entertained a
significant legalization compromise in 2018.
Which brings me right back to the question
with which I began.
WHAT IF TRUMP IS PREPARING THE
DEAL OF THE CENTURY?
What if we have misunderstood what we are
watching?
What if Donald Trump has established the
strongest possible enforcement position
because he believes that Washington will
never produce a meaningful immigration
agreement without pressure?
What if the Democrats, confronted with
continued deportations and growing
humanitarian concerns, eventually conclude
that they must negotiate?
ion
agreement without pressure?
What if the Democrats, confronted with
continued deportations and growing
humanitarian concerns, eventually conclude
that they must negotiate?
And what if the president then comes
forward with an offer?
Secure the border.
Prioritize the removal of dangerous
criminals.
Establish enforceable consequences for
future illegal entry.
Require existing undocumented residents
who qualify for relief to register, undergo
screening, comply with the law, and pay a
substantial penalty.
Provide conditional lawful status while they
fulfill their obligations.
And create a defined legal process for
resolving their immigration status.
Imagine Congress debating that agreement.
Imagine a president whose political identity
has been built around strong border
enforcement proposing a settlement that
also addresses the millions of people already
living here.
ne a president whose political identity
has been built around strong border
enforcement proposing a settlement that
also addresses the millions of people already
living here.
Imagine Democrats having to decide
whether they will accept a compromise that
includes serious enforcement measures.
Imagine Republicans having to decide
whether they will accept a compromise that
allows some people who entered unlawfully
to earn legal status.
Neither side would receive everything it
wants.
That is the nature of negotiation.
And perhaps that is precisely why such a
deal has proved so difficult for so many
years.
Now, could Donald Trump accomplish it?
That depends upon Congress, the actual
terms of the legislation, and the willingness
of both parties to negotiate.
And was this his plan all along?
I cannot prove that.
ish it?
That depends upon Congress, the actual
terms of the legislation, and the willingness
of both parties to negotiate.
And was this his plan all along?
I cannot prove that.
There is another possibility: perhaps the
president has simply recognized changing
political circumstances and is reconsidering
how his enforcement priorities should be
applied.
Or perhaps both things are true.
Perhaps he has always been willing to
negotiate, but the political circumstances
have changed the timing and the terms of
the negotiation.
That is why I am watching what happens
next.
Not merely what the president says.
Not merely whom he appoints.
But whether he actually places a
comprehensive immigration proposal before
Congress.
Because that is where speculation ends and
governing begins.
Not merely whom he appoints.
But whether he actually places a
comprehensive immigration proposal before
Congress.
Because that is where speculation ends and
governing begins.
AND WHAT ABOUT THE MONEY?
Now, I want you to consider the financial
implications of my proposal.
Suppose eight million people qualified for a
program carrying a $10,000 penalty.
If every participant paid the full amount, that
would represent $80 billion in gross
assessments.
Eighty billion dollars!
Of course, that is a hypothetical calculation,
not a government revenue forecast.
Some people would fail to qualify.
Some might be unable to pay.
Some might default.
And administering such a program would
cost money.
But it demonstrates why the financial
structure deserves consideration.
ify.
Some might be unable to pay.
Some might default.
And administering such a program would
cost money.
But it demonstrates why the financial
structure deserves consideration.
Congress could determine whether penalty
revenue should help pay for border security,
immigration courts, application processing,
and enforcement.
And perhaps a portion could be directed
toward improving the lawful immigration
system itself.
I would want an independent fiscal analysis
before promising the American people that
such a program would pay for itself.
But the potential scale is substantial enough
to warrant examination.
And I would insist upon something else.
The people who followed the law must not
be forgotten.
The families who waited overseas.
The applicants who paid the required fees.
The immigrants who endured the lawful
process.
They deserve fairness as well.
ust not
be forgotten.
The families who waited overseas.
The applicants who paid the required fees.
The immigrants who endured the lawful
process.
They deserve fairness as well.
Any comprehensive reform must account for
those who obeyed the rules, not merely
those who violated them.
WE MUST NOT CONFUSE MERCY WITH
WEAKNESS
Now, I want to speak to my fellow
conservatives one final time.
Because I know that some of you are going
to disagree with me.
And that is perfectly fine.
But I want you to consider something.
Is a government weak because it establishes
different penalties for different violations?
Is a government surrendering its sovereignty
because it allows an offender to satisfy a
financial penalty rather than imposing the
most severe available consequence?
Is there no room in conservative thought for
proportionality?
For restitution?
ender to satisfy a
financial penalty rather than imposing the
most severe available consequence?
Is there no room in conservative thought for
proportionality?
For restitution?
For accountability?
For mercy?
I believe there is.
And as a minister of the Gospel, I cannot
discuss this subject without remembering
that justice and mercy are not necessarily
enemies.
Micah 6:8 declares:
“He hath shewed thee, O man, what is
good; and what doth YAHWEH require
of thee, but to do justly, and to love
mercy, and to walk humbly with thy
Elohim?” — Micah 6:8
Notice that.
Do justly.
Love mercy.
Not justice without mercy.
And not mercy without justice.
Both.
justly, and to love
mercy, and to walk humbly with thy
Elohim?” — Micah 6:8
Notice that.
Do justly.
Love mercy.
Not justice without mercy.
And not mercy without justice.
Both.
Now, I am not suggesting that a biblical
passage supplies the details of federal
immigration legislation.
Congress must do that work.
But I am suggesting that our moral principles
should inform how we think about the people
affected by our laws.
And I refuse to accept the proposition that a
person must abandon compassion in order
to support national sovereignty.
I refuse to accept the proposition that
supporting border security requires us to
ignore the circumstances of every family
facing removal.
And I refuse to accept the proposition that
holding someone accountable always
requires imposing the harshest available
consequence.
MY PROPOSAL TO PRESIDENT
DONALD TRUMP
Mr. President, if you are listening, I want to
put an idea before you.
able always
requires imposing the harshest available
consequence.
MY PROPOSAL TO PRESIDENT
DONALD TRUMP
Mr. President, if you are listening, I want to
put an idea before you.
You have already demonstrated that you are
serious about immigration enforcement.
You have already made border security a
defining issue of your presidency.
You have already established that you are
willing to use the authority of the federal
government to remove people who are
unlawfully present.
But perhaps the next chapter of your
immigration legacy could be something
larger.
Perhaps it could be a comprehensive
agreement that accomplishes what previous
administrations and Congresses have failed
to accomplish.
Secure the border.
Remove dangerous criminals.
Establish accountability for immigration
violations.
Create a lawful and conditional process for
qualifying longtime residents.
.
Secure the border.
Remove dangerous criminals.
Establish accountability for immigration
violations.
Create a lawful and conditional process for
qualifying longtime residents.
Protect American families wherever the law
permits.
Respect those who followed the lawful
immigration process.
And prevent the same crisis from recurring.
I am proposing a $10,000 accountability
penalty as a starting point for discussion.
I am proposing background checks,
registration, tax compliance, and
enforceable deadlines.
I am proposing that qualified participants be
permitted to remain and work lawfully while
fulfilling those obligations.
And I am proposing that Congress establish
a clearly defined legal status available only
after those requirements are satisfied.
I am not proposing that everyone
automatically receive citizenship.
I am not proposing that serious criminals be
excused.
vailable only
after those requirements are satisfied.
I am not proposing that everyone
automatically receive citizenship.
I am not proposing that serious criminals be
excused.
And I am certainly not proposing that
America abandon control of its borders.
I am proposing that the government
consider a different legal remedy for a
defined group of people already living within
our country.
Mr. President, perhaps such an agreement
could become part of your legacy.
Not simply as the president who demanded
stronger immigration enforcement.
But as a president who helped bring
Congress to an enforceable immigration
settlement.
THE FINAL QUESTION
Folks, I want to leave you with one final
thought.
We have spent decades arguing about
immigration.
Republicans demanding enforcement.
Democrats demanding relief.
INAL QUESTION
Folks, I want to leave you with one final
thought.
We have spent decades arguing about
immigration.
Republicans demanding enforcement.
Democrats demanding relief.
Families caught in the middle.
Communities divided.
And Congress repeatedly failing to produce a
lasting solution.
Meanwhile, the problem continues.
So perhaps it is time to ask a different
question.
Not whether America should enforce its
immigration laws.
Of course it should.
Not whether people who violate those laws
should face consequences.
Of course they should.
But whether Congress can establish
consequences that are firm, lawful,
proportionate, and capable of resolving the
status of millions of people without
abandoning national sovereignty.
That is the discussion I want to have.
that are firm, lawful,
proportionate, and capable of resolving the
status of millions of people without
abandoning national sovereignty.
That is the discussion I want to have.
And perhaps—just perhaps—Donald Trump
is preparing to have that discussion as well.
Was the aggressive enforcement the
opening demand?
Was the political pressure part of the
negotiating leverage?
Is Stephen Miller's prominent role helping
preserve that leverage?
And could the eventual agreement be
something neither party was willing to
consider before?
I don't know.
But I intend to watch closely.
Because sometimes the most important part
of a negotiation is not where the negotiator
begins.
It is where the agreement ultimately lands.
And if Donald Trump can bring Republicans
and Democrats together around a workable
immigration settlement that combines
or
begins.
It is where the agreement ultimately lands.
And if Donald Trump can bring Republicans
and Democrats together around a workable
immigration settlement that combines
genuine enforcement with meaningful
accountability and a lawful resolution for
qualifying families, that would be a major
legislative achievement.
Whether that is his intention remains to be
seen.
But the opportunity for a serious national
conversation is right in front of us.
And I believe it is time we had it.
And that, Class, is something worth thinking
about.
Because I see what he's doing.
And tomorrow — you'll see it too.
DEEP DIVE: CONQUERED BY THE
SWORD — CONVERTED BY THE TAX
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: MAP — ALEXANDRIA • ANTIOCH
• CARTHAGE • CONSTANTINOPLE ]
Now let me ask you a history question they
never asked you in school.
How did Egypt become Muslim?
TAX
[ SHOW GRAPHIC: MAP — ALEXANDRIA • ANTIOCH
• CARTHAGE • CONSTANTINOPLE ]
Now let me ask you a history question they
never asked you in school.
How did Egypt become Muslim?
How did Syria become Muslim?
How did Turkey become Muslim?
How did Morocco become Muslim?
Most Americans think they were always that
way.
Or that they converted peacefully one
Sunday morning.
No, Class.
Alexandria.
Antioch.
The land of Augustine.
These were the HEARTLAND of Christianity
—
when much of Europe was still bowing to
trees.
And they were CONQUERED.
Syria — in the 630s.
Egypt — by 641.
North Africa — by the year 700.
Anatolia — broken open at Manzikert in
1071.
Constantinople — 1453.
And what was the grievance?
There was only ONE.
They were infidels.
Don't take my word for it.
Chapter 9, verse 29.
Fight them — "until they give the jizyah...
while they are humbled."
Now here's the part they don't teach you.
Egypt didn't convert overnight.
Egypt stayed Christian for CENTURIES after
the conquest.
Because the conquerors didn't need to kill
every Christian.
They just made it EXPENSIVE to be one.
t convert overnight.
Egypt stayed Christian for CENTURIES after
the conquest.
Because the conquerors didn't need to kill
every Christian.
They just made it EXPENSIVE to be one.
Taxed.
Humbled.
Second class.
Generation after generation —
until the grandchildren gave up.
Write it down:
They were conquered by the sword —
and converted by the tax.
And the Coptic Christians of Egypt are still
there tonight — millions of them — fourteen
hundred years later.
Still refusing to bow.
A faith that has to be FORCED isn't a faith.
It's an OCCUPATION.
THE JIHADISTS' PLAN FOR AMERICA
And if you think that's ancient history —
listen.
[ PLAY VIDEO: "YOUR TIME IS UP" ]
[ ON-SCREEN TITLE: THE JIHADISTS' PLAN FOR
AMERICA ]
Did you hear him, Class?
"Your time is up."
"Your borders are fading."
"We reject your flags."
"It won't be long before it is YOU that will be
feasted upon."
That's not my translation.
That's not a Fox News chyron.
That's HIS mouth.
HIS words.
HIS plan.
And here's what should keep you up at
night:
he's not hiding it.
He's ANNOUNCING it.
t's not my translation.
That's not a Fox News chyron.
That's HIS mouth.
HIS words.
HIS plan.
And here's what should keep you up at
night:
he's not hiding it.
He's ANNOUNCING it.
Every generation of jihadists has told the
West exactly what they intend to do.
And every generation of Western leaders has
said — "Oh, he doesn't really mean it."
Egypt didn't believe it.
Syria didn't believe it.
Constantinople didn't believe it.
When a man tells you he's coming for your
flag —
BELIEVE HIM.
Guard the border.
Know who's coming in.
And never — EVER — apologize for loving
your own country.
[ TRANSITION STING ]
️ SEGMENT 4 — LAND OF
OZ
Duration: ~9 minutes
THE FIRST SENATOR TO SWEAR ON
THE QUR'AN
Welcome to the Land of Oz — where the
Wizard hides behind the curtain, and
somebody has to pull it back.
Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan has been elected
the first Muslim in the history of the United
States Senate.
And he's expected to become the first
senator to take the oath of office on the
Qur'an.
And my phone has been ringing all week.
"Professor — WHY is that ALLOWED?"
I'll tell you why.
Because the Founders wrote it that way.
Article Six, Clause Three: