Back to search

No, Alex Pretti Did Not Have a Right to That Weapon

FHMI-1713Professor Toto2026-02-01Commentary Article

Searchable index text

This text comes from the vector search index, so keyword links can open directly to searchable content.

"ap"(0 of 0)
Use arrow keys to move between matches

Showing 0 matches for "ap" in the transcript below.

Title: No, Alex Pretti Did Not Have a Right to That Weapon Summary: Professor Toto argues that Alex Pretti, though a permit holder, forfeited the protection of his right to carry when he joined a network tracking ICE and physically interfered with federal officers — a felony under 18 U.S.C. § 111. Under Barnes v. Felix and the totality-of-circumstances standard, officers who heard 'gun' during the struggle reasonably perceived a deadly threat. He predicts the officer will not be charged and urges people to obey officers and fight in court. No, Alex Pretti Did NOT Have a Right to That Weapon The Supreme Court Already Answered. Professor Toto — TOTO FREE PRESS · Published 2026-02-01 · https://professortoto.substack.com/p/no-alex-pretti-did-not-have-a-right ________________ By Professor Toto ________________ Folks, sit back down. I know what you’ve been hearing all week. Every talking head on cable news. Every blue-check pundit on X. Every screaming protester in Minneapolis. “Alex Pretti had a constitutional right to carry that weapon!” No. He. Didn’t. ng head on cable news. Every blue-check pundit on X. Every screaming protester in Minneapolis. “Alex Pretti had a constitutional right to carry that weapon!” No. He. Didn’t. Let me explain. And I’m going to give you something the mainstream media won’t—the truth. The whole truth. The legal truth. WATCH THE VIDEO HERE ________________ The Facts They Don’t Want You to Know Alex Pretti had a Minnesota concealed carry permit. He completed the mandatory training course. Under normal circumstances, he had every legal right to carry a firearm. But here’s what the media won’t tell you. Circumstances weren’t normal. And that changes everything. ________________ A Constitutional Right Is Not a Constitutional Blank Check Having a fundamental right doesn’t mean you can exercise it in any context without consequences. You have a fundamental right to free speech. That doesn’t mean you can commit perjury on the witness stand. You have a fundamental right to peaceably assemble. That doesn’t mean you can storm a federal building. You have a fundamental right to bear arms. But that does not mean you can bring a gun to commit a felony. aceably assemble. That doesn’t mean you can storm a federal building. You have a fundamental right to bear arms. But that does not mean you can bring a gun to commit a felony. Listen to me carefully, class. The right remains. When you exercise that right in the commission of a crime**, you forfeit its protection.** Period. ________________ What the Video Actually Shows Now, I want to be careful here because there’s an ongoing investigation. But let’s talk about what we know. Pretti didn’t stumble onto this scene by accident. He wasn’t walking to get coffee when he suddenly encountered federal agents. He was part of a Signal app group—a sophisticated network of activists tracking ICE movements in real time. According to reports reviewed by multiple news outlets, encrypted messages show that “rapid responders” were actively tracking federal agents outside that donut shop on Nicollet Avenue before shots were ever fired. They tracked license plates. They documented vehicle movements. They summoned “backup” to the location. And Pretti went there. Deliberately. Intentionally. To interfere with federal law enforcement conducting a lawful operation. movements. They summoned “backup” to the location. And Pretti went there. Deliberately. Intentionally. To interfere with federal law enforcement conducting a lawful operation. That, my friends, is where the trouble begins. ________________ The Legal Framework Nobody’s Talking About Under 18 U.S.C. § 111, it is a federal crime to forcibly assault, resist, oppose, impede, intimidate, or interfere with any federal officer performing their official duties. Read that again. Impede. Interfere. You don’t have to throw a punch. You don’t have to fire a weapon. Impeding and interfering with federal officers conducting lawful duties is itself a criminal act. * Recording officers from inches away while they’re making an arrest? That’s interference. * Getting physically involved while officers are conducting a detention? That’s assault on a federal officer. That’s a felony. * Resisting when officers attempt to detain you? Another felony. When you’re actively engaged in felonious conduct, your constitutional right to carry a firearm while committing that felony evaporates. That’s not Professor Toto’s opinion. That’s the law. ________________ elonious conduct, your constitutional right to carry a firearm while committing that felony evaporates. That’s not Professor Toto’s opinion. That’s the law. ________________ The Supreme Court Has Spoken Now I know many of you students are going to question your esteemed Grand Professor tonight. “Where does the law say this, Toto?” I really ought to charge for all this education. Barnes v. Felix (2025). Just last year, the United States Supreme Court—in a unanimous 9-0 decision—addressed the standard for evaluating use of force by law enforcement. Justice Kagan, writing for the Court, reaffirmed the “totality of the circumstances” standard from Graham v. Connor. Here’s what that means in plain English: An officer is entitled to consider everything happening around them when reacting to a threat. Officers don’t have to be correct in their perception of danger. They have to have a reasonable perception of danger based on the totality of circumstances. When officers hear the word “gun”… When an object is moving in someone’s hand… When that person is actively engaged in conduct constituting a felony… ity of circumstances. When officers hear the word “gun”… When an object is moving in someone’s hand… When that person is actively engaged in conduct constituting a felony… When that person has no legal protection to carry that weapon because they’re using it in the commission of a crime… There is a reasonable perception of deadly threat. And according to Barnes v. Felix, the law is on their side. ________________ The Timeline That Matters Let’s walk through what the available evidence shows: 8:58 AM — Pretti is filming federal officers conducting a detention on Nicollet Avenue. The Signal network had already been tracking agents in the area. 8:58-9:00 AM — Officers attempt to move Pretti back. He continues approaching, phone in hand. 9:00 AM — Physical contact begins. Officers attempt to detain Pretti. 9:01 AM — During the struggle, officers discover Pretti is armed. Someone shouts “Gun!” And in the seconds that follow, officers perceive a deadly threat from a man who: ti. 9:01 AM — During the struggle, officers discover Pretti is armed. Someone shouts “Gun!” And in the seconds that follow, officers perceive a deadly threat from a man who: * Was committing federal crimes by interfering with officers * Was resisting detention * Was carrying a loaded firearm with multiple magazines * Made movements that could reasonably be perceived as threatening Was the shooting tragic? Absolutely. Was it murder? That’s not what the law says. ________________ The Investigation Will Run Its Course I’m not drawing final conclusions about whether Pretti drew his weapon or pointed it at anyone. The investigation is ongoing. Body camera footage from multiple angles exists and is under review. But here’s what we don’t need an investigation to know: When you actively seek out confrontation with federal law enforcement… When you’re part of a coordinated network deliberately tracking and interfering with lawful operations… When you bring a loaded firearm to that confrontation… You’re not a “bystander.” You’re not an “innocent citizen.” You’re a participant in criminal conduct. wful operations… When you bring a loaded firearm to that confrontation… You’re not a “bystander.” You’re not an “innocent citizen.” You’re a participant in criminal conduct. And when things go bad, you don’t get to claim the constitutional protections you forfeited when you decided to break the law. ________________ The Wisdom They Don’t Teach Anymore You want to know how to survive an encounter with law enforcement? I’ll give you the secret—and it’s free: Obey. Don’t approach officers conducting an operation. Don’t physically interfere. Don’t resist when they give you commands. That’s not bootlicking. That’s not surrendering your rights. That’s survival wisdom as old as civilization itself. You can fight your legal battles in court. You can file complaints. You can advocate for policy changes. But you can’t do any of that if you’re dead. When you look for trouble, you’ll find it. And in Minneapolis, apparently, they get mad when they find what they’re looking for. ________________ The Bottom Line Alex Pretti did not have a constitutional right to carry that weapon in the manner he was carrying it that day. nd what they’re looking for. ________________ The Bottom Line Alex Pretti did not have a constitutional right to carry that weapon in the manner he was carrying it that day. Not because the Second Amendment doesn’t exist. Not because Minnesota doesn’t have concealed carry. Because you cannot exercise a constitutional right in the commission of a felony. The Supreme Court has settled it. Barnes v. Felix. The totality of circumstances. The reasonable perception standard. When this investigation is over, that officer will walk. Because what happened on Nicollet Avenue wasn’t murder. It was survival. ________________ And Now You Know... THE BEST of the Story. ________________ Professor Toto is the host of the Conservative College podcast and Substack. For more truth they don’t want you to hear, subscribe today.

Summary

Professor Toto argues that Alex Pretti, though a permit holder, forfeited the protection of his right to carry when he joined a network tracking ICE and physically interfered with federal officers — a felony under 18 U.S.C. § 111. Under Barnes v. Felix and the totality-of-circumstances standard, officers who heard 'gun' during the struggle reasonably perceived a deadly threat. He predicts the officer will not be charged and urges people to obey officers and fight in court.

Source document

Original source document

This teaching is shown above as searchable text so readers can jump directly to matched words.

Open source