Back to search

Netanyahu Ousted? Not So Fast! Here's How Israel's Government Really Works

FHMI-1523Professor Toto2026-11-09Commentary Article

Transcript

No exact match for "'for those who know'" in this transcript. This result may have matched scripture references, topics, or other metadata—check sections above.

NETANYAHU OUSTED? NOT SO FAST! HERE’S HOW ISRAEL’S GOVERNMENT REALLY WORKS! Why Israel Has Both a President AND a Prime Minister — And Why the Man Who Wins the Most Seats Doesn’t Always Get to Govern! Professor Toto — TOTO FREE PRESS · Published 2026-11-09 · https://professortoto.substack.com/p/netanyahu-ousted-not-so-fast-heres ________________ **By Professor Toto | TOTO FREE PRESS……**Tomorrow’s News Today. Beyond The Headlines ________________ Folks, I want to take a few minutes today and teach you something about Israel that I suspect many Americans have never fully understood. HOW IN THE WORLD CAN ISRAEL’S PRESIDENT REMOVE BENJAMIN NETANYAHU AND HAND THE GOVERNMENT TO SOMEBODY ELSE? After all, isn’t Netanyahu the prime minister? Didn’t his political party win more seats than any other party in the recent election? And who is this President Herzog, anyway? I thought Netanyahu was running Israel! Well, he is. And that is where our American understanding of government can get us into trouble. Because, ladies and gentlemen, ISRAEL DOES NOT HAVE THE SAME KIND OF GOVERNMENT THAT AMERICA HAS. Once you understand that one simple fact, the entire story begins to make sense. So today, Professor Toto is taking you back to school. No complicated political science. No fancy language. Just a simple lesson about how the government of Israel actually works. And by the time we’re finished, you’ll understand why the headlines announcing Netanyahu’s removal are getting ahead of the facts. FIRST, ISRAEL HAS TWO MEN AT THE TOP! Here is where the confusion begins. In America, we have one president. Donald Trump is both the head of our nation and the head of our federal government’s executive branch. He represents America before the world, and he directs the executive branch of our government. But Israel separates those responsibilities between two different offices. Israel has a PRESIDENT and a PRIME MINISTER. And they do two very different jobs. Let me introduce you to them. ISAAC HERZOG — PRESIDENT OF ISRAEL Think of President Herzog as being somewhat like King Charles in Great Britain. Now, Israel does not have a king, and Herzog is certainly not royalty. He is elected by Israel’s parliament to serve a seven-year term. But his job is much closer to that of the British king than to that of the American president. He represents the nation. He performs important official duties. And when Israel needs a new government, he helps begin the process of forming one. But he does not ordinarily run the government. He does not sit there making the daily decisions that Netanyahu makes. He is the HEAD OF STATE. Now, let’s look at the second man. BENJAMIN NETANYAHU — PRIME MINISTER OF ISRAEL Netanyahu is the man who actually leads the government. He directs government policy. He leads the cabinet. He works with Israel’s military and security leadership. He makes the major decisions of government. He is the HEAD OF GOVERNMENT. Are you beginning to see the difference? In Great Britain, King Charles is the head of state, but the prime minister runs the government. In Israel, President Herzog is the head of state, but Prime Minister Netanyahu runs the government. THE PRESIDENT REPRESENTS THE STATE. THE PRIME MINISTER RUNS THE GOVERNMENT. Remember that distinction, because everything else depends upon it. SECOND, ISRAEL DOES NOT ELECT ITS PRIME MINISTER THE WAY WE ELECT OUR PRESIDENT! Now, this is where things get interesting. In America, we hold a presidential election. The voters choose presidential electors, and through the Electoral College, a president is elected for a four-year term. But that is not how Israel works. Israel has what is called a PARLIAMENTARY GOVERNMENT. Don’t let that big word frighten you. It simply means the government depends upon the support of the nation’s elected parliament. Israel calls its parliament the KNESSET. And the Knesset has exactly 120 members. Think of it as Israel’s version of Congress, although the two systems work differently. Here is what happens. When Israelis go to vote in a national election, they vote for political parties, not personalities. Those parties receive seats in the Knesset according to how many votes they receive, provided they meet the required election threshold. One party might win 27 seats. Another might win 21. Another might win 15. And several smaller parties might divide the rest. But here is the problem. THERE ARE 120 SEATS, AND NO SINGLE PARTY HAS ENOUGH TO CONTROL THE GOVERNMENT BY ITSELF! That means political parties must work together. And that brings us to one of the most important words in Israeli politics. THIRD, WHAT IN THE WORLD IS A COALITION? A coalition is simply a group of political parties that agree to work together to form a government. Let me make this as simple as I possibly can. Imagine you have 120 people sitting in a room. They belong to several different political groups. One group has 27 people. Another group has 21. Another has 15. And several smaller groups have the remaining members. Now, suppose the group with 27 members says: “We won the most seats! Therefore, our leader should run everything!” Not so fast! Because 27 members cannot control a room of 120 people. They need help. So they begin talking to the smaller groups. They make agreements. They negotiate over policies. They decide who will receive important positions in the government. And they try to put together enough support to govern. That is called BUILDING A COALITION. In a 120-member parliament, 61 members make up an outright majority. That is the number everybody is looking at. And here is something that may surprise you. THE PARTY THAT WINS THE MOST SEATS DOES NOT AUTOMATICALLY GET TO FORM THE GOVERNMENT! Let me say that again. The largest party does not automatically get to govern. What matters is whether somebody can put together a government that wins the confidence of parliament. That is how a man whose party finished second can sometimes become prime minister. And THAT, my friends, brings us to what just happened to Benjamin Netanyahu. FOURTH, WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED IN ISRAEL THIS WEEKEND? Israel held its national election on October 27, 2026. Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud party won 27 seats. His main challenger, Gadi Eisenkot, led the Yashar party, which won 21 seats. So Netanyahu’s party actually won MORE seats than Eisenkot’s party. But remember what I just taught you. Winning the most seats does not automatically give you control of the government. After the election, President Isaac Herzog began meeting with representatives of the different political parties. He wanted to know one thing: WHO DO YOU RECOMMEND TO TRY TO FORM THE NEXT GOVERNMENT? And here is what happened. * 67 members recommended Gadi Eisenkot. * 46 members recommended Benjamin Netanyahu. * 7 members declined to recommend either man. Now, those numbers are important. President Herzog looked at those recommendations and concluded that Eisenkot should receive the first opportunity to form a government. So on Sunday, November 8, Herzog officially gave Eisenkot that assignment. And immediately, the headlines began screaming about Netanyahu being ousted. But hold on! NETANYAHU HAS NOT BEEN REMOVED FROM OFFICE BY THE PRESIDENT! President Herzog did not fire him. He did not throw him out of the prime minister’s office. And Eisenkot did not automatically become prime minister. What happened was much simpler. EISENKOT WAS GIVEN THE FIRST OPPORTUNITY TO TRY TO BUILD A NEW GOVERNMENT. There is a world of difference between being asked to form a government and actually succeeding in forming one. FIFTH, EISENKOT STILL HAS A BIG PROBLEM! Now, here is the part of the story I find especially interesting. Remember those 67 members who recommended Eisenkot? You might think that means he already has 67 members ready to support his government. But that is not necessarily true! You see, recommending somebody to try to form a government is not the same thing as agreeing to serve in that government. And that distinction is creating a serious problem for Eisenkot. His four-party political alliance holds 48 seats. Netanyahu’s political bloc holds 53 seats. And the Arab-led parties hold another 19 seats. Those Arab-led parties helped give Eisenkot the recommendations he needed to receive the assignment from President Herzog. But Eisenkot has ruled out forming a governing coalition with those parties. Do you see the difficulty? Some of the people who recommended that he receive the opportunity to form a government are not necessarily people he is willing to bring into his government! That means he must negotiate with other parties. And those parties have their own demands. Some disagree about military service. Some disagree about religious policies. Some disagree about Netanyahu. And some disagree about whether they should cooperate with the Arab parties. GETTING PEOPLE TO AGREE ON WHO SHOULD TRY TO FORM A GOVERNMENT IS ONE THING. GETTING THEM TO AGREE ON AN ACTUAL GOVERNMENT IS SOMETHING ELSE ENTIRELY! And that is why Netanyahu’s political future is not yet settled. SIXTH, HOW MUCH TIME DOES EISENKOT HAVE? Under Israeli law, Eisenkot initially has 28 days to form a government. The president may give him up to 14 additional days. That means he could have as long as six weeks. During that time, he must negotiate with other political parties and try to put together a government capable of winning a confidence vote in the Knesset. If he succeeds, he becomes prime minister when the Knesset approves his government. Netanyahu then leaves office. But what if Eisenkot fails? The president can give another member of the Knesset an opportunity to form a government. That could include Netanyahu. And if the entire process breaks down, Israel could eventually face another election. In the meantime, Netanyahu continues serving as prime minister until a new government takes office. So the story is not over. Not by a long shot. SEVENTH, LET ME EXPLAIN THIS WITH A CHURCH CONVENTION! Now, folks, I want to give you an illustration that I believe will make this perfectly clear. Imagine a large church organization holding a national convention. There are 120 delegates. Several different groups have been elected to represent the membership. One group has 27 delegates. Another group has 21 delegates. And the rest are divided among smaller groups. The group with 27 delegates is the largest group in the convention. But the group with 21 delegates begins talking to the smaller groups. They say: “If you will support our candidate for president of this convention, we will work with you on the issues that matter to your group.” And before long, that smaller group has gathered enough support to win the leadership vote. Now, tell me something. Did the largest group automatically deserve to control the convention? No! Not under those rules. Because the convention’s leadership is determined by the support of the delegates, not simply by which individual group has the most members. That is the basic idea behind Israel’s parliamentary system. And remember, the Israeli president is not the man who makes the final decision about who governs. The new government must still win the confidence of the Knesset. FINALLY, HERE IS WHAT I WANT EVERY AMERICAN TO UNDERSTAND! When you read international news, you must understand that other nations do not necessarily operate under the American system. We have a presidential system. Israel has a parliamentary system. Great Britain has a parliamentary system with a constitutional monarch. Israel has a parliamentary system with an elected president. And in both Israel and Great Britain, the prime minister leads the government. So the next time you see a headline declaring that Israel’s president has appointed somebody to form a new government, don’t imagine that the president has simply fired the prime minister. That is not what happened. He has started a constitutional process. And until that process produces a government capable of winning parliamentary confidence, the political struggle continues. HERE ARE THE FIVE THINGS I WANT YOU TO REMEMBER: 1. Israel has a president, but he is not the person who ordinarily runs the government. 2. Israel’s prime minister is the nation’s chief political executive. 3. Israel’s citizens elect a 120-member parliament called the Knesset. 4. Political parties must work together to form a government that can win parliamentary confidence. 5. Benjamin Netanyahu has not been automatically removed simply because President Herzog asked Gadi Eisenkot to form a government. And there you have it! What sounded like a complicated international political crisis is actually much easier to understand once you know how the system works. THE LARGEST PARTY DOES NOT AUTOMATICALLY GOVERN. THE GOVERNMENT MUST HAVE THE CONFIDENCE OF PARLIAMENT. That, my friends, is the lesson. And as for Benjamin Netanyahu? His future now depends upon what happens during these coalition negotiations. Eisenkot has been given the first opportunity. Whether he can actually put a government together remains to be seen. So don’t confuse a political assignment with a completed transfer of power. They are two very different things. This is Professor Toto, reminding you that before you can understand tomorrow’s news, you’ve got to understand how today’s world actually works. Welcome to TOTO-TOWN, where we don’t just read the headlines. WE LEARN WHAT THEY MEAN! Professor Toto TOTO FREE PRESS — Tomorrow’s News Today. ________________ Sources and further reading * Office of the President of Israel — November 8, 2026, official announcement assigning Gadi Eisenkot the task of forming a government. * The Knesset — Forming a Government, official explanation of Israel’s parliamentary process. * Reuters — November 8, 2026, reporting on Eisenkot’s coalition negotiations and the election results. * The Jerusalem Post — November 8, 2026, analysis of the disagreements among potential coalition partners.

Summary

A civics lesson after headlines claimed Netanyahu had been 'ousted'. Professor Toto explains that Israel separates head of state (President Herzog, elected by the Knesset for seven years) from head of government (the Prime Minister), and that Israelis vote for parties, not personalities. A government needs the confidence of 61 of the Knesset's 120 members, and the largest party does not automatically govern. After the 27 Oct 2026 election (Likud 27, Yashar 21), 67 members recommended Eisenkot, so Herzog gave him the mandate on 8 Nov. But Eisenkot has ruled out governing with the Arab parties whose recommendations he received. Netanyahu stays prime minister until a new government wins a confidence vote.

Source document

Original source document

This teaching is shown above as searchable text so readers can jump directly to matched words.

Open source